How Durable are Wood Countertops?

How Have the Wood Countertops Held Up to Daily Use?
The countertops we purchased were oak. They are holding up beautifully-for the most part. The biggest area of issue is where it is to be expected. Right around the sink.Most of the main countertop I’ve sealed every year and has done really well, but it is constantly getting wet there and being wiped down. It’s easy to reseal them, its just a matter of wiping the sealer on before bed and they are ready to go the next morning! A year later I would do them all over again.

What Kind of Maintenance Do Wood Countertops Take?
-We use the sealer from Ikea and it’s super easy to use. I chose to not use a sealer like Waterlox because I wanted to be able to control the depth of the color. If you use a sealer where you do the entire thing like that of you ever have to fix a stain, you have to sand down the entire section and re-sand so it all seals the same. Now I can just sand down a section and reseal.
-Don’t cut directly on the countertop
-Make sure to use a safe sealer
-I do not put hot pans on my counter top, I use a marble slab for that.But I do still love them and would do them all over again! Check out this post with the review 8 years later!

The rule of thumb is if water can’t sit on the surface for 10 minutes with out being absorbed they need to be resealed.
And any thing that might stain needs to be wiped upright away. We had a pickled beet jar sit on the counter overnight and it left a red ring. I sanded it and resealed it in about an hour and it was done. With a natural stone it would’ve been there forever, the same with a lighter laminate.

The Biggest Issue with Wood Butcher Block Countertops?
Our biggest issue has been around the sink, and specifically behind the faucet. It tends to stay wetter and stain quite bit. We do get some pooling because of faucet placement and that there is constantly water on it. That is one of the biggest drawbacks of the wood countertops. We don’t have much space behind the faucet and it’s really hard to keep dry. If I had to do it over again, I would actually find a sink that went up to the backsplash and cover the wood completely.

Do Butcher Block Countertops Change Color?
We have notice they have darkened slightly over time but not so much that we don’t like it. Even though our cabinets have changed colors several times, and we’ve even added a tile backsplash, for the most part they have kept their original color.

Are Wood Countertops Worth It?
I think so! They were really affordable, have held up well, and look nice! I would do them all over again.

What a great post! I have been thinking of replacing our countertops with wood and my friends think I’m crazy. (I have granite and I’m a little ‘over it.’)As for the firefighter stuff–I have often heard that the most trusted people in the US are firefighters. Which kind of segues into do-it-yourself advisor nicely, I think.
I just discovered your blog this month and am really enjoying it.
Love this post! I’m considering reaching out to local businesses to sell my products. Is there a rule of thumb on the percentage the business should keep from the sale of an item?
Thanks for your tips and Happy New Year!
Abby
Loved reading this Jennifer…knowing more about who you are from who you have been and how your tenacity has kept you going in new directions. Quite inspiring!
I also value that you share information readily…so many people keep their secrets to themselves…your generosity is not just refreshing it is valued!
Great post. Love the firefighter pic. Happy New Year. Hugs, Marty
I am patiently waiting for my walnut counter top to be installed. Was nice to hear that you still love yours after a year. Susan
Jen love this post! Your countertops look beautiful, I love the color of the paint in your Kitchen. I always enjoy your blog! Have a wonderful 2012!
You are such an interesting person, Jennifer! I only started following you recently and I must make time to go back to your older posts. Your home is just lovely and I took a quick peek in your Etsy, too. Lovely stuff! I look forward to getting to know you better. Happy New Year!
Thank you all for such nice comments! Abby, with wholesaling, it depends on the place. Some places do a 50/50 split, Some places 40/60 and some places will buy outright. It’s important when you sell somewhere for you to decide if it’s worth your while or not.Make sure you are at least getting back your supplies plus. This may be a great post on it’s own!
Happy New Year!!
Great post Jennifer! I love the countertops and sure loved seeing your feature in Country Living.
Nice guns in the picture on the stage! 🙂
Happy 2012 and thank you for the inspiration in 2011!
Take care,
Pam
You rock, Jen!
Just look at those guns on you, I love it!
I’m still loving your wood countertops, too.
I also love how you are not afraid to get out there and make things happen…heck, even “ambush” someone if need be. I’m the same way!
Wishing you a wonderfully Happy New Year!
XOXO,
Anne
look at those guns sister!
impressive
funny – both of us Anne’s commented on your guns 🙂
I love Q&A posts!!! Happy 2012 to you, too!
To tile your kitchen countertops is actually a very good thought and you will find lots of tile solutions out there in which to choose from. It seriously depends upon your budget as to which tiles you opt for and some supplies are more high priced than others.